HCR Law Events

Our People

Esther Stirling, Partner, Head of Agricultural Dispute Resolution

Dispute Resolution

Direct Dial: 03301 075 972
Mobile: 07525 594 998

A bit about me

When it comes to agricultural and equine litigation, I work on the principle that there is no point having an argument about having an argument. Rather, it’s about stepping back and try to be objective about the problem, while I form a constructive relationship with the other side to get the job done. I’m a strong advocate of alternative dispute resolution and mediation, and if a case doesn’t need to go to court, I’ll do everything I can to keep it out of one.

I’m passionate about farming – if I weren’t a water and fishery lawyer, I would have certainly been a farmer instead! I’ve built up a national reputation in my field, and regularly present and lecture on contentious issues concerning agricultural land. I relish the challenge a lot of my work presents and there’s nothing more satisfying than knowing that I’ve helped a family or business to keep farming well.

I represented the successful tenant in the important case of Herefordshire District Council v Bayliss [2019] 9 WLUK 147 (First-tier Tribunal Property Chamber), the first decision in England and Wales concerning the service of certain notices to quit of Agricultural Holdings Act tenancies.

As a horse-owner myself, I love racing and have been actively involved in point-to-point events for years. I also love walking in the British countryside; to me, there’s no finer place on Earth.

Want to know more?

Write things down. Even if you know the other person really well, you’ll be far better protected if you have a written record of your agreements in the event that you fall out.

Keep talking: whether landlord and tenant, neighbours or commercial partners, communication breakdowns – sometimes, totally innocent ones – are almost always behind disputes.

Stand your ground, but be reasonable: there is always benefit in settling a dispute early on.

Can my landlord make me leave my farm or grazing land? 

It very much depends on what law governs your occupation. Usually, they need to follow a particular process very carefully.

My neighbour’s activities mean I cannot enjoy my own land. Do I have a remedy?

If what they are doing amounts to a nuisance, you may be entitled to damages or an injunction. However, I would need to look carefully at how a court would balance the use and enjoyment each party makes of their land.

I have been sold a horse that is dangerous. What can I do?

We need to establish whether there has been a breach of contract, or whether the contract was based on a false statement. You may then be entitled to return the horse, or to damages. We may need an independent professional to assess the horse first.

Where I work

Endorsements & Awards

Read my
latest articles

HCR backs new AgriTech Zone at Three Counties

Taking farming into the future, the new AgriTech Zone at the Three Counties Showground, backed…

Read full article

Dogs and horses – worrying times?

With lambs and ewes in the field at this time of year, dog walkers will…

Read full article

No longer a game of Guess Who? Dealing with unknown trespassers

There have been several high-profile instances of animal rights and environmental campaigners entering farmland uninvited…

Read full article

Leading by example: Herefordshire farmers collaborate to tackle phosphate pollution

There is no doubt that there have been recent algal blooms in the River Wye.…

Read full article

Fairhurst v Woodard – ringing the changes on domestic surveillance?

Headlines about the privacy row over a smart doorbell will have no doubt had many…

Read full article

Watch Now: Your Future Farm

 In this webinar you will hear business and legal insights from our nationally leading…

Read full article

Australia trade deal: opportunity or threat?

The trade deal between the UK and the Australian governments certainly marks a moment of…

Read full article

Farming for the future – which way ahead?

From ‘the tweeting farmer’ (otherwise known as outspoken advocate of sustainable and regenerative farming, Gareth…

Read full article

Meet The Speakers - Future of Farming Forum

Britain's agricultural landscape is one of diversity.  From hardy Shetland cattle to rich Cornish dairy,…

Read full article

Got a question?

Send us an email

Newsletter HCR featured image

Stay up to date

with our recent news