AI tools are fast becoming part of everyday business life. Marketing teams use them to brainstorm, brand managers use them to mock up ideas and many of us now drop an image into a chatbot to ask, “Can you make the logo bigger?” or “What would this look like in blue?”
It feels quick, harmless and private. But depending on what that image contains, the answer to “Is it ok?” is not always as simple as it seems.
There are a few examples I could draw on. An important focus is when an organisation uses third-party designers. Designers and creative agencies increasingly see customers upload their artwork to AI platforms to share feedback and request changes. Most customers do this without a second thought.
Few realise that, depending on the tool, they may be sharing that artwork far more widely than intended, with potential consequences for both their own brand and the rights of others.
Who owns commissioned artwork?
A common assumption is that if you pay for a piece of artwork, you own it. Not necessarily.
Under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 (CDPA 1988), copyright in an original artistic work generally belongs to the person who created it, unless they created it in the course of their employment. When you commission an external designer or agency, the starting point is that they keep the copyright, unless the contract says otherwise.
Ownership can be transferred, but only by a written assignment signed by the owner. Without one, what you usually have is a licence: permission to use the artwork in certain ways and for certain purposes.
Once rights have been transferred, the original owner needs permission to keep using the work. The same logic applies in reverse: if you only hold a licence, you need to stay within its terms.
So, before doing anything new with commissioned artwork, including uploading it to an AI tool, it’s worth checking what your contract actually says. Do you own the copyright, or do you have a licence? And if it is a licence, does it cover this kind of use?
Licensed characters and brands: an extra layer of risk
Things become more complicated when the artwork features someone else’s intellectual property, such as a well-known cartoon character, film franchise or famous logo.
Designers who create products featuring these characters do so under licence agreements with the brand owners. Those agreements are typically detailed, strictly enforced and set out exactly how the licensed content can be reproduced, shared and adapted.
Uploading licensed content to an AI platform could involve copying it onto a third party’s systems or making it available for uses the licensor never agreed to. If that falls outside the licence terms, it could put the designer in breach of its licence and expose the person who uploaded it to an infringement claim.
Where does your image go?
The less obvious risk is what happens to an image once it has been uploaded. Depending on the tool and how it is set up, uploaded content may be:
- Stored on the provider’s servers, sometimes for a long period
- Reviewed by the provider’s staff or contractors, for example for quality or safety checks
- Used to train or improve the AI model.
If your artwork is used for training, elements of it could, in theory, influence what the tool produces for other users. Even if that risk is small, it’s not one you can easily undo.
For a business that has paid for a design created exclusively for its brand, that is a real concern. A design that has been shared beyond your organisation is harder to keep exclusive and potentially harder to protect.
Enterprise or consumer: does it matter?
Yes, a great deal. Not all AI tools are equal.
Free or consumer versions of popular platforms often allow the provider to keep and use what you upload, unless you actively change the settings. Business or enterprise versions usually come with contractual commitments that your content will not be used for training, will be kept confidential and will be deleted after a set period.
In short, using a secure enterprise tool that your organisation has approved is a very different proposition from pasting artwork into a free app on your phone. The terms of use and the settings you choose make all the difference.
So, is it ok?
It depends. If the artwork features third-party licensed characters, logos or brands, the short answer is no, unless you have clear written confirmation that it is permitted.
For other commissioned artwork, it may be ok, provided you have the right to use it in that way and use a tool that keeps your content secure.
Before uploading commissioned artwork into any AI tool, we recommend you consider the following:
- Check your contract: do you own the copyright or do you have a licence, and does it cover this use?
- Look for third-party content: if the artwork includes licensed characters, logos or brands, do not upload it without written permission
- Read the tool’s terms: find out whether content is stored, shared or used for training and change the settings where you can
- Use approved, secure tools: where possible, use enterprise versions that your organisation has approved and that do not keep or train on your content
- Talk to your designer: if in doubt, ask before uploading. Many designers are now issuing their own guidance on AI use
- Put a policy in place: clear internal rules on AI use will help staff and collaborators avoid accidental disclosure.
This is a fast-moving area, and brand owners’ positions on AI are still developing. There’s no one-size-fits-all answer to “Is it ok?”, and each situation will turn on its own contracts and facts.
We recommend seeking legal advice if you’re unsure about your rights in commissioned artwork or concerned that content may have been shared in breach of a licence.